data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/70d06/70d06b2f44968f01f81e21aa7f598e33441b1a2f" alt=""
I've never read the prequel to this book, "A Teacher's Funeral," but had assumptions about it based on the humorous cover and general reviews. So, when I had a free moment I picked it up. And was surprised. Not in a good or bad way, just surprised. At 141 pages, it's a short little thing and the overall look is clearly middle school. The story, of a tomboy who works on cars but discovers another path in life, was definitely middle school focused. I guess what surprised me was the complex storytelling. Vocabulary and historical references (the book is set in 1914) are specific, and far above the heads of most teen readers, I would think (heck, I didn't even understand some of them). The book is humorous, my favorite line being "Well, we read very little, but we don't mind if others does. We're Methodist." I just have no idea who it would appeal to. There are extreme details of cars of the period but little action, so I don't see guy appeal. Lots of discussion of clothing as well, but almost too much? The period was set well in the first chapters, I do feel it was belabored after that. Peck writes like Twain, his vernacular is right on point. But I would think that is likely to distance a contemporary reader who knows nothing of the era. All in all, it was cute and had moments, but it wasn't a page-turner and I see it as a niche book -- one that will just have to find the right person to truly appreciate it.
No comments:
Post a Comment