SPOILERS AHEAD
It gets Superman right. He's wholesome. Legitimately. And that alone makes this better than most of the Superman films which came after Christopher Reeve (that being said, I do have a soft spot for Brandon Routh). It's dark, but not as dark as the last few films. The politics, which were reported as "subtle" is anything but, and since it's my politics, I appreciated the digs. Nathan Fillion makes a delightful turn as a corporate shill superhero. Rachel Brosnahan, who I love, is rightly perky and determined as unstoppable Lois Lane. The dog is adorable.
But.
There is a lot of action. Like, a lot. Like every superhero film these days, it is battle after battle after battle. Even my stepfather, who loves Superman and was the reason we entered a movie theatre for the first time in a very long time, said it was too much. Perhaps at the expense of story.
There are all the elements. The characters we have come to love (including Cat Grant??? and a somewhat more world-wise Jimmy), the fortress (inexplicably set in Antarctica, not the Arctic, which creates a moment of disbelief which is hard to swallow ... do these people not realize that the Arctic is solid ice and Antarctica is a land mass??? I digress ...) But few of the characters outside of the leads get more than a line or two of dialog. There is no fleshing out of, well, anyone. Including Lex Luthor.
And that's a problem. I'm a fan of Nicholas Hoult, and first picked up on him in the brilliant and underrated series, "The Great". But he's not ... "it". The character is just a self-obsessed bully. And not only is that hard to play, it doesn't make for a good foil. Lex is best when actors bring humor to the role, add in levels. Gene Hackman let Lex really enjoy it all. John Shea played it with such a level of class that you ~~almost~~ could see the attraction. This Lex is either not written, or the actor directed, to do much more than snarl and yell and direct his minions and his robot. It's like a sad version of a dark Ironman. And so, without a great enemy ... well, you get it.
There are also minor irritations. Ma and Pa Kent are played like country bumpkins, and this is the second time in a week I've seen rural people portrayed that way. Also, does Supergirl really have to be a drunk social media influencer? Of course, the female superhero is dismissed as a joke. Not cool, Hollywood.
There will be a sequel. There are a million unaddressed threads. And, a possible enemy worth fighting. Maria Gabriela de Fabria makes for a creepy-as-hell adversary and there are some real questions about a message left by Jor-El and Superman's Kryptonian mom. We'll see. Probably takes a couple of years for another film to be put together. I'm mildly interested in where they go from here, but would love more story, more development of the characters. It's okay to have big fights. But maybe less???