And the Award Goes to ...

And here we are again.  SAG Awards, 2025.  Below, my thoughts and my votes.

FILMS:  “Meh”.  Beautiful filming but few, if any, films which raised the bar.  Favorites included women-forward films like “Emilia Perez” and “The Last Showgirl”.  There were tired themes done well – cognitive decline in “The Great Lillian Hall” and another musician biopic where the women are set pieces in “A Complete Unknown”.  There were creepy-as-hell films, “The Substance” and “The Piano Lesson”.  Clever films which made you think, like “The Brutalist”, “Conclave” and “A Real Pain”.  “Sing Sing” brought tears aplenty.  At least one film I loathed, “Anora” (it ran rampant on my feminist sensibilities) and the sparkly fun of “Wicked”.  But nothing which rocked the boat.  Films which made an impact but nothing that said, “Wow”.  A so-so year for so-so times.

This year’s nominees in the STREAMING/TELEVISION category were … bleak.  But not bleak like in past years, where themes of death and loss have prevailed.  Bleak as in film noir.  Dark.  Violent.  Depraved.  Ugly.  I swear, if I heard “psychological thriller” or “true crime” one more time, I was going to hurl.  There is a morose malaise which filters through nearly every project.  Can’t say I enjoyed many of them, including the comedies. Even some of the so-called funny stuff had an “edge” (although “Nobody Wants This” was charming).  There was just a prevailing sense of hopelessness and few characters you really wanted to succeed.  Not my speed.  I will say, however, that almost universally, the “filmmaking” aspect of the shows was extremely high.  “Ripley”, “True Detective:  Night Country”, “The Penguin”, “Baby Reindeer”, “Disclaimer” and “Under the Bridge” were nothing if not artful and beautifully brought to screen.  In the end there was only one drama which truly drew me in.  “Shogun”.  It is a cinematic masterpiece with Shakespearean overtones.  A showcase for brilliant actors.  A sensitive and layered script.  I had put off watching it because I knew there were lengthy subtitles, but once I started in, I could not turn away.  Paradoxically, it is large screen in concept and yet humbling and very real in execution.  These aren’t characters, they are people.  Are there bad guys?  Sure.  But every single role is multi-dimensional.  There are no simple reasons for anyone’s behavior.  There are even laughs now and then, as there are in real life.  Colonialism is dealt with realistically while the Japanese culture is respected and put at the forefront.  I would hesitate to say that this treatment of the famous Clavell novel is about the conqueror.  It is about the nation he stumbles into and the people trying to make the best of bad hands.  Worth the time.  And the tears.

Deciding on my votes was difficult.  In some cases, there was an overabundance of choices, in other cases no choices at all.  Below are the ones I settled on.

The Motion Picture Nominees are:

Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Leading Role
ADRIEN BRODY / László Tóth - "THE BRUTALIST"
TIMOTHÉE CHALAMET / Bob Dylan - "A COMPLETE UNKNOWN"
DANIEL CRAIG / William Lee - "QUEER"
COLMAN DOMINGO / Divine G - "SING SING"
RALPH FIENNES / Lawrence - "CONCLAVE"

Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role
PAMELA ANDERSON / Shelly - "THE LAST SHOWGIRL"
CYNTHIA ERIVO / Elphaba - "WICKED"
KARLA SOFÍA GASCÓN / Emilia/Manitas - "EMILIA PÉREZ"
MIKEY MADISON / Ani - "ANORA"
DEMI MOORE / Elisabeth - "THE SUBSTANCE" 

Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Supporting Role
JONATHAN BAILEY / Fiyero - "WICKED"
YURA BORISOV / Igor - "ANORA"
KIERAN CULKIN / Benji Kaplan - "A REAL PAIN"
EDWARD NORTON / Pete Seeger - "A COMPLETE UNKNOWN"
JEREMY STRONG / Roy Cohn - "THE APPRENTICE"

Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Supporting Role
MONICA BARBARO / Joan Baez - "A COMPLETE UNKNOWN"
JAMIE LEE CURTIS / Annette - "THE LAST SHOWGIRL"
DANIELLE DEADWYLER / Berniece - "THE PIANO LESSON"
ARIANA GRANDE / Galinda/Glinda - "WICKED"
ZOE SALDAÑA / Rita - "EMILIA PÉREZ"

Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN
ANORA
CONCLAVE
EMILIA PÉREZ
WICKED

Outstanding Action Performance by a Stunt Ensemble in a Motion Picture
DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE
DUNE: PART TWO
THE FALL GUY
GLADIATOR II
WICKED

The Television Program Nominees are:

Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Television Movie or Limited Series
JAVIER BARDEM / Jose Menendez - "MONSTERS: THE LYLE AND ERIK MENENDEZ STORY"
COLIN FARRELL / Oz Cobb - "THE PENGUIN"
RICHARD GADD / Donny - "BABY REINDEER"
KEVIN KLINE / Stephen Brigstocke - "DISCLAIMER"
ANDREW SCOTT / Tom Ripley - "RIPLEY"

Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Television Movie or Limited Series
KATHY BATES / Edith Wilson - "THE GREAT LILLIAN HALL"
CATE BLANCHETT / Catherine Ravenscroft - "DISCLAIMER"
JODIE FOSTER / Det. Elizabeth Danvers - "TRUE DETECTIVE: NIGHT COUNTRY"
LILY GLADSTONE / Cam Bentland - "UNDER THE BRIDGE"
JESSICA GUNNING / Martha - "BABY REINDEER"
CRISTIN MILIOTI / Sofia Falcone - "THE PENGUIN"

Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Drama Series
TADANOBU ASANO / Kashigi Yabushige - "SHŌGUN"
JEFF BRIDGES / Dan Chase - "THE OLD MAN"
GARY OLDMAN / Jackson Lamb - "SLOW HORSES"
EDDIE REDMAYNE / The Jackal - "THE DAY OF THE JACKAL"
HIROYUKI SANADA / Yoshii Toranaga - "SHŌGUN"

Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Drama Series
KATHY BATES / Madeline Matlock - "MATLOCK"
NICOLA COUGHLAN / Penelope Featherington - "BRIDGERTON"
ALLISON JANNEY / Vice President Grace Penn - "THE DIPLOMAT"
KERI RUSSELL / Kate Wyler - "THE DIPLOMAT"
ANNA SAWAI / Toda Mariko - "SHŌGUN"

Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Comedy Series
ADAM BRODY / Noah Roklov - "NOBODY WANTS THIS"
TED DANSON / Charles Nieuwendyk - "A MAN ON THE INSIDE"
HARRISON FORD / Paul - "SHRINKING"
MARTIN SHORT / Oliver Putnam - "ONLY MURDERS IN THE BUILDING"
JEREMY ALLEN WHITE / Carmen "Carmy" Berzatto - "THE BEAR"

Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Comedy Series
KRISTEN BELL / Joanne - "NOBODY WANTS THIS"
QUINTA BRUNSON / Janine Teagues - "ABBOTT ELEMENTARY"
LIZA COLÓN-ZAYAS / Tina - "THE BEAR"
AYO EDEBIRI / Sydney Adamu - "THE BEAR"
JEAN SMART / Deborah Vance - "HACKS"

Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series

BRIDGERTONTHE DAY OF THE JACKAL
THE DIPLOMAT
SHŌGUN
SLOW HORSES

Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series

ABBOTT ELEMENTARY
THE BEAR
HACKS
ONLY MURDERS IN THE BUILDING
SHRINKING

Outstanding Action Performance by a Stunt Ensemble in a Television Series
THE BOYS
FALLOUT
HOUSE OF THE DRAGON
THE PENGUIN
SHŌGUN

 

"Leave the World Behind" by Rumaan Alam

Soon to be a Netflix series coming to you.  (Spoilers) I've read way (way, way, way) too many post-apocalyptic books.  This one was different.  It was the beginning of the apocalypse -- which isn't completely defined.  When the reality of the event becomes clear, the book is done.  In the meantime, we have explored racism, culture, privilege, family dynamics and ... a lot more.  It's a literary novel (finalist for the National Book Award) which is meandering, cerebral, maybe even a touch lazy in pacing.  It examines very normal people in extraordinary times.  There are few heroes here, but there aren't clear-cut villains, either..  Most of the reponses are ... well ... real.  The result, for me, was a tinge of sadness.  That when the worst comes, people don't rise above.  That's the lesson we always try to tell to children, that the good people run towards the fire.  This book makes it clear that such a take might be a fairytale.  The truth of calamity is complex and layered, and often not something which brings out our better natures.  Which left me feeling ... ?  I will be very interested in how a nuanced story like this translates onto the screen.

"Go Set a Watchman" by Harper Lee

(Spoilers) For lovers of "To Kill a Mockingbird" this is a hard pill to swallow.  Written before Mockingbird, which acts as a prequel to this tale, we see here an adult "Scout" returning to her hometown.  She has the experience so many of us have -- seeing our heroes with new eyes when nostalgia meets hard reality.  She (and the readers) see the flaws glossed over in Mockingbird.  It is a more nuanced tale.  Scout is trying to find her place in the world, and finding herself in the process.  She turns to her father, Atticus, only to find an aging man who is more racist than she ever imagined.  He believes in the law, but not in equality for Blacks.  The man she looked up to spouts replacement theory, talking about the "invasion" of mongrels. the book starts slowly but quickly becomes rich with the prose which made Harper Lee such a good writer.  Scout's internal dialog ebbs and flows with bits of conversation around her, weaving the story together like a tapestry.  There are lots of memorable and noteworthy quotes, many which are very applicable to today's America.  The book ends more with intellectualism than heart, however, and there are no clear answers.  "To Kill a Mockingbird" was a terrific lesson on our nation's dark history, but this book is a balancing note of where we went from there.

"Descendants"

This film was so innocuous I actually watched it twice, unaware of having seen it before when I watched it the second time.  While sweet and cute, it is also absolutely unmemorable.  It's a typical Disney film of late.  Decent, if not outstanding actors lost in a watercolor haze.  Songs are nice but not catchy.  Dialog is inoffensive, plotlines are gentle, the climax doesn't ... climax.  While the ingredients are there the end product is like a bread that doesn't rise.  It's okay.  Just not fabulous.  And not memorable.