Yay! So often, with
series, the energy of the first book cannot be sustained. Not so with Meyer’s “Lunar Chronicles” which
has tripled its “cast” in this third book and is still a fun page-turner with
a nicely original spin on some very old stories (Fairy Tales in a Science
Fiction future). Cress, the newest
character in the series, is, in some ways, more intriguing to me than Scarlet,
the lead in the second novel. Trapped in
isolation, she is child, savant, and hopeless dreamer. It is easy to like her amidst Cinder’s
hardness and Scarlet’s pathos. Other
characters join the fray and one gets a sense of “Beauty and the Beast” meets “Star
Wars” in this latest installment. Meyer
does a terrific job of balancing the paths of each character but maintaining
enough forward momentum that you can’t wait until there is resolution. Sadly, resolution will not be found here, as
a fourth, yet-to-be published, book is on the horizon. Nonetheless, some of my frustrations with hanging plotlines from
the first book are resolved a bit, and there is some loss as well. I can only hope that when all is said and
done, Marissa Meyer will fulfill my need to read “And they lived happily ever
after” as she wraps things up. At the
moment, that doesn’t seem likely, but this is a series that has defied
expectations, time and time again. Given
how satisfying this book was, I do believe it can happen …
Here’s for low expectations.
I went in thinking this was yet another pale “Hunger Games” rip-off,
only to be pleasantly surprised. It is
Dystopian, and it does have a plucky, if not sometimes whiny and nearly indestructible
heroine (think Jack Bauer). There is a
cute guy with a dark side and a fair number of predictable plotlines, but all
that being said, I really liked it. The
book is well-written, the actual plot somewhat unique – unique enough that it
did not feel “derivative” (as one of my students said) and the characters are
well-rounded, complex enough to hold my interest. The book is, as a whole, quite a
page-turner. It is easy to see the teen
appeal – good girl goes bad, complete with dangerous stunts, black clothes and
tattoos, but I never felt like Ms. Roth talks down to her readers. A fairly young author herself, the voices
come across as authentic, even as these teens struggle to figure out their role
in life. I liked it enough that I now
want to see the movie, with images in my head strongly in place. A warning for readers … it is violent. There are a number of brawls that result in significant
injury, and a sharp item gouged into one young man’s face. These incidences are described in very
specific detail. With all books, readers
can, and do, choose to breeze through sections that might disturb them, but
like other Dystopic tales, it might be best to give a head’s up to younger
readers.